The real test of a trauma-informed organisation begins when somebody says "NO".
Some of the most controlling organisations I've encountered have also been the loudest about being trauma informed.
Some of the most controlling organisations I've encountered have also been the loudest about being "trauma informed". There I said it and I bet many agree.
The real test of a trauma-informed organisation begins when somebody says "NO".
I've worked alongside organisations that described themselves as experts in trauma-informed practice. Some were well-funded, recognised and publicly celebrated for their work.
Yet behind the language of empowerment and person-centred support, I witnessed approaches that left me questioning who was actually in control.
People having their lives managed for them. Professionals deciding what was best. Support plans shaped around organisational priorities. Staff advocating on behalf of people while sometimes giving insufficient attention to what those people actually wanted.
And somehow, this was presented as empowerment.
We've become very good at describing what trauma-informed practice looks like. I'm considerably less convinced we're always as good at delivering it.
Scotland's National Trauma Transformation Programme identifies five central principles: safety, trust, choice, collaboration and empowerment.
The Scottish Government's own trauma-informed guidance specifically discusses giving people meaningful choices, a voice in decisions and opportunities to share power.
So the question for organisations is fairly straightforward.
What happens when someone receiving support disagrees with you?
Imagine someone refusing a referral, questioning a support plan or choosing a goal their worker doesn't particularly like.
- Does the organisation become curious about their reasoning?
- Does it help them understand their options and potential consequences?
- Or does the disagreement become another problem the professional needs to manage?
Because there's a worrying tendency in some services to confuse professional expertise with authority over another person's life.
And the more vulnerable somebody is perceived to be, the easier it can become to justify that control.
I'm not dismissing safeguarding. There are genuine risks, legal responsibilities and circumstances where intervention is necessary.
But safeguarding decisions need to be justified, proportionate and transparent. They shouldn't provide a blanket excuse for replacing people's preferences with professional ones.
What concerns me just as much is how we measure success.
I've seen organisations attract praise and substantial funding while operating in ways that appeared to contradict the principles they promoted.
That doesn't prove the funding was wrongly awarded or that every aspect of their service was poor.
It does raise questions about what we're rewarding.
A completed training programme doesn't prove an organisation shares power.
An excellent funding application doesn't tell us whether someone feels listened to.
And an impressive case study doesn't necessarily establish who made the decisions behind the successful outcome.
I'd like to see boards, commissioners and funders asking much more demanding questions.
Who sets the person's goals?
What happens when they reject professional advice?
Can they challenge a decision without damaging their relationship with the service?
And what evidence exists that people's opinions have actually changed how the organisation operates?
Those questions tell us considerably more than the number of trauma-informed training certificates hanging on the wall.
I'm sure there are many outstanding organisations and practitioners doing this properly. I've worked with people whose respect for individual choice was fundamental to everything they did.
But good practice elsewhere doesn't excuse poor practice here.
And calling an organisation trauma informed shouldn't protect it from scrutiny. If anything, the claim should invite closer examination.
Here's the test I'd put to every organisation that describes itself as trauma informed.
When someone says, "No. That's not what I want", what happens next?
Because if their wishes only matter when they agree with the professionals, we need to stop congratulating ourselves on how empowering our services are.
You don't have to be cruel to take someone's power away. Sometimes all you need is the absolute conviction that you know what's best for them.
Think about that for a moment.